I wrote this post way back in September – almost 9 months back. Never posted it because I didn’t think people would be interested to read, that it would be received properly, that it would be okay for me to speak up…… but today, SatyaMev Jayate has encouraged me to share this story. A patient from Baroda, and an observer in me; here goes:
18th September, 2011
I am an optimist. I may be sad or low or I may just start crying… but I am an optimist at heart.
When I walk into an office, my first instance is to believe that I am in a noble place. That the people there are sincere. That the work they do is honest. That they wish to do well and do just.
But something really moved me yesterday.
It all started last week.
A friend sent me a text that his mother is in the government hospital, admitted to the ICU because of a high diabetic condition. I decided to pay a visit and offer to help. I just had the regular “Hey bud! Lemme know if you need anything!” and the “Hey Mate! Don’t worry… all will be fine.” – Dialogues ready in my head. But when I stepped in there, I just couldn’t leave.
This was the government hospital of Baroda – the place where people from all over Gujarat come for treatment. There are patients from far of districts and even other states like Rajasthan; who come here with faith to be cured.
My first feeling was optimism.
We take my friend’s mom to the first ward. The doctor looks at the swollen foot and says, “Take her to the other department. This is a case of diabetes being severe. Control that first, and then come here.”
We rush her to the other ward, and there the authorities tell us “the wound is severed. The swelling is critical. First aid is required. The leg has to be dealt with first, before we look begin with treatment for diabetes.”
My otherwise troublesome friend is rather quiet and I step in, “they have just sent us here. So, it would be really nice if you could confirm where we are to go”. My friend rushes to the other surgical department, to the doctor to bring him to this department so that treatment can begin soon. The doctor comes, comments “well!! I sent her here because it was your case of diabetes … but if you are not taking her, we will start our procedures. She anyway has to be admitted.”
My instinct is disturbed by the lack of coordination.
But then I watch as the doctors sending us to the ward; the interns scolding my friend for not getting the syringe in time ( ; ) ), the doctors doing the rounds and I helping in the tests – I feel like appreciating the work. I feel overwhelmed thinking of how they are working in this set up; treating the underprivileged, giving their whole to so many patients.
After spending the weekend there, I return home thinking- yes! The system may be flawed, but it still isn’t all shallow and hollow. There are people working for humanity. There are people doing their job really well. There are people who are passionate and care. I felt good about the treatment meted to my friend’s mother.
However, my happiness was soon to be tainted.
The following day, I was discussing the case with a colleague. I had previously done some social work in terms of copy writing, for his Grandfather’s trust. He brought to my notice that since the trust operated close to the Hospital, and since my friend’s mom was in the same hospital, I should refer the case to them at least once before the surgery that was scheduled in the afternoon.
Well! It made sense. No harm in getting one more perspective on the case. I reached the hospital with agenda but to be greeted by my friend, in tone of happiness. “Apsara!! All is fine now! Mom is being discharged.”
I am pleasantly surprised and credit all the ‘good news’ to the positive colors that I am wearing : )
We walk down to pay the bills. On the way, I look at the trust office and suggest having a word them. Since everything was good now, we could just tell the people at the trust that all is fine. My colleague has after all, taken the trouble to connect us.
However, from that point onwards, everything changed.
The NGO people meet us with great warmth and positivity and my colleague’s grandfather volunteers with all the energy to look into the subject and to meet the doctors with us. He comes with us.
He says, “Oh! Let’s meet the doctors if your mother is being discharged.”
He walks straight in and asks about details.
Apparently, the diabetic department that had given us “discharge on request” (despite us never making any such request) and the authority explains that they had to do this because they could not treat my friend’s mother for the ailment. It was the job of another department.
The intern explains, “The lady was brought in a critical condition. We presumed that the swelling was because of a tissue infection. And the infection would have affected the bone. But; the swelling in the tissues occurred only in 2 – 3 days; which means that the bone could not have been infected by the tissue infection. For a bone to be infected, the condition has to be longer; for instance, in terms of months. So the fact is that the bone was initially infected and this infection spread to the tissues. Our department doesn’t deal with bone problems. The bone infection has to be cured by the orthopedic department and it must because that’s what has transferred contagion to the tissues.”
So if there is a bone infection, why was she being discharged with a mere mention that there has to be regular dressing of the foot?
And the answer is: THAT is not our work.
The doctor explains, “The orthopedic department was not taking her. What can we do about it? So, our work is to deal with tissues. If they don’t admit her for a bone treatment, we have no option but to send her home and that’s what we were doing.”
My colleague’s grandfather, looks at us and says, “Don’t discharge her today. Stay a day. We’ll look into it and talk to the highest authorities.”
He takes us straight to the senior doctors and explains the case.
Within 10 minutes, we are back in a ward and the 4 doctors are here to see her.
(The reason is the NGO. The NGO is renowned for its good work. So, when they are associated with a case, they manage to get answers.)
The doctor inspects the foot, confirms that my friend’s mother has to be shifted to the orthopedic department and the procedures begin in few minutes.
I just stand there spell bound.
I help in the processes and running about. I help in the shifting.
But deep within, I am terribly disturbed.
Today, we were on the verge of committing a big mistake. We were taking my friend’s mom home with an almost fatal infection. We were going to quietly bring her for a dressing the foot – every day for perhaps a month- so that her open wound could heal (the incision that was made to inspect and clear the region with the swelling. And for records, the swelling has only partially subsided, and the foot looks far from normal).
We were going to go home smiling, thinking that she was being discharged because thing were fine. Not knowing, that it was because there was no one to check and sign her papers.
I had wondered last week, why I was there…. At the hospital… when I should actually be studying or working or doing something of personal importance… and yesterday I realized WHY.
It was so that I could open my eyes and see the world, not through tainted glasses.
We, the educated, were going to fall prey to negligence, then what would be the case of the under privileged? The poor? The uneducated?
I still feel, the doctors are doing a great job out there. Working hard day in and day out. Treating patients and healing them. But what disturbs me is the thin line between “work” and responsibility.
There were professional’s out there, who were willing to let a patient suffer because it wasn’t a matter of their department. Knowing well, that the condition could worsen, that it could lead to a critical amputation or extreme condition of the infection spreading in the entire body…. Knowing… that….. Sending this patient home is not the right thing to do…. They knew it…. But they were still about to go through with it.
I never really wanted to be a doctor. And now I think, with the idealist that I am, I’d have suffered more if seniors around me were dealing with patients like this.The hope, however, lies in the hands of the young minds that are sincere and the experienced professionals from the field who are role models.
I can understand the Munna Bhai MBBS dialogue, “Ek doctor ke liye ek mariz ek bimar sharer hai. Bus.” But… at the end of the day, that ill body is a human being.
I can understand them being un-moved by illnesses, by ailments, by these critical conditions. What I cannot understand is how they can be indifferent.
I cannot understand how we can go to bed knowing that somebody is suffering before our eyes, and that we could do what was required to treat them. This diabetic department/ surgical department may not be responsible for the procedure of curing……. But they could bring forth the case to the ortho-department.
The patient’s relatives on the other hand, suffer not just trauma but also confusion. They have to file papers, transfer papers, sign documents, get medicines, shift the patient themselves form one ward to the other and above all, remaining in the dark about what exactly is happening.
The first thought that came to my mind was that, I am an Indian.
I have lived in this India.
I have walked the dirty streets, I have worked in dingy buildings and I have seen the sarkari daftar (slow working offices). I am still tolerant when it comes to postal, police and railway procedures … but this is a HOSPITAL. And this is a matter of life and death. We just cannot be tolerant here.
If you have managed to read this article and reach till this point, then here are two things:
- Pray for my friend’s mom : ) She’s still needs are good wishes and still needs to be treated for the bone condition
- Don’t be *starry* eyed and believe everything around you. Ask questions, be alert and HELP where you can. Perhaps you could help someone in pain and in need. It needs only an educated mind. Please share this post.
For now, I am too un-rich to be able to help this NGO in spreading the light, but when I can, I shall. Until then, I am going to make posts like this, volunteer with time and spread the word.
You can do the same and perhaps help someone in need.
I guess the positive colors did work after all 😉 we met the Hari Om Seva Trust. And God bless them for the wonderful social service they are doing.
As Of Today: 26th May 2012
The Trust [Link to their Facebook Page –sharing the name and link on request]still operates in Baroda helping thousands of under privileged patients with subsidized health care medications and the correct information about their ailments.They host camps, educate and do a lot of voluntary service and have been recognized internationally.
My friend’s mom – finally underwent an amputation. The amputation was needed to avoid the infection from spreading. She walks with a Jaipur/false foot now and is fine.
As for me, I am still *starry eyed*, yet wiser; have many questions [While at it, you can Like the blog page here: Half A Cup Of Tea. Please do!] I am still moved by instances and this is but, one story. If there’s anything you need me to help with, please feel free to get in touch.
Inspired by cause addressed by Staya Mev Jayte – even if the series is making a lot of money, targeted for TRP, it’s still getting us to talk about subjects. Their success is justified, in the same way, as I bring out this post and justify sharing something like this without facing the wrath of society and “higher authorities”.
Satya Mev Jayate – it’s the truth after all, why fear?
God Job 🙂 Definitely a must read article !
Thanks sachin!! 😀 u read it without me having to tell you to read it? 😀 wow!! and glad you liked it … do share it along. Warm wishes!
Good one Apsara (S) its really reality …
Thanks for reading!:)
Am proud of you dear…..keep it up….
Thanks sumathi mami 🙂 glad u read!
hope it makes even a small difference somewhere ….. warm wishes!
Very well written i must say AND VERY WELL SAID U CANT BE TOLERABLE in case of hospital coz its a matter of life and death
Thanks for reading Mayank 🙂 Wishes!
Amazing Job ! A salute for dis post..Thank u 🙂
Thank you Keertika 🙂 for reading… do share and spread the word! Guess you are new to the blog? welcome! please do Like the blog page!:) warm wishes
very well done apsara mam… gr8 job
Thanks for reading Jigu! Do like the page and share the words. Appreciate thoughts 🙂 warm wishes
The article reminded me of my mother. She had diabetes and a severe infection on her foot. She suffered for months due to health departmental negligence. Finally she had gone for amputation.
Carry on the good work.
Thank you for the appreciation Tanmay. Hope your mother is fine and hope notes like this can help in improving the system. Warm regards 🙂
She tried her best to come back to regular life with her artificial leg. But unfortunately one day she fell on the floor. This accident broke her second leg and her willingness to live life. Finally she left us in Dec 2006. She is with God now, resting peacefully.
Really sorry to hear about your mother… May her soul rest in peace. It is really sad. The friend who’s mom suffered, lost his dad to a similar situation few years back. Amputation and then illness. Hope people become aware and hope we can contribute to improving the system so that less people suffer. Amen!
The experience of the blogger is sad and unfortunate.It is said that Govt Hospitals are the best if you know some one there .I am speaking from experience of this and other Govt Hospitals in India.The Govt health services are similar in all countries including USA UK with slight variations
Thanks for the support Parthvii. More aware people like us can help bring a change! Warm wishes 🙂
More than mere carelessness, its also doctor’s inability. Healthcare system is under horrendous cycle. We need to dig deeper into the system and find out the real truth. There are lot of things related to this.
1. State of Govt hospitals is miserable and they can no longer provide good healthcare services.Even if a healthy person visits Govt hospital there are chances that he may fall sick.
2. Private hospitals have become increasingly expensive. The moment doc hears about medical insurance, he puts up huge bill
3.Now lets talk about how doctors are made,there are around 2000 seats for mbbs in gujarat. Out of which around 1000 seats are in general category. Overall, there are around 1000 good quality doctors new in the state every year serving population of more than 5 crores. There are very few seats in govt colleges so naturally people opt for private colleges.Fees for private colleges is around 7.5 lakhs per annum.Under management quota the total sums upto 50 lakhs per seat including fees and so called donation. For masters the sum goes to 1 crore.
4. After working so hard and after spending soo much of money, person would obviously like to recover money.If a doctor works at a govt hospital, his starting salary is Rs 25k per month which hardly reaches upto 60k at the time of retirement He earns lot more than this if we works for a private hospital or opens his own clinic.Naturally few good quality doctors are ready to work with govt hospitals.
5. Its pure business.Everyone involved wants to make money playing with lives of innocent patients.
Having said that, there are some are some exceptions too. My uncle is a reputed doctor in Gujarat. I have seen hand written letters from patients thanking him for saving their lives. I believe that medicine is a noble profession. Saving a person’s life is above everything else.
[…] are more reactions in the blogosphere. Half a cup of tea shares a story of maltreatment in a hospital, inspired by Aamir's show on “Corruption in […]
[…] are more reactions in the blogosphere. Half a cup of tea shares a story of maltreatment in a hospital, inspired by Aamir's show on “Corruption in […]
[…] are more reactions in the blogosphere. Half a cup of tea shares a story of maltreatment in a hospital, inspired by Aamir’s show on “Corruption in […]
I know this types of i have never suffered before in SSG Hospitl baroda previously it was realy good, but now a days peoples are not going to baroda hospital preferred to goto private hospital . Same type of help i wanted to do so whch NGO of baroda i can contact.